Study | Clear Definition of Study Population | Clear Definition of Outcomes and Outcome Assessment | Independent Assessment of Outcome Parameters | Random Sequence Generation (Selection Bias) | Allocation Concealment (Selection Bias) | Blinding of participants and Personnel (Performance Bias) | Sufficient Duration of Follow-Up | No Selective Loss During Follow-Up | Important Cofounders and Prognostic Factors Identified |
Slotman 199812 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Van den Akker 201113 | + | + | + | + | + | + | × | + | + |
Rampersaud 201125 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | × | + |
Wang 201216 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Pelton 201217 | + | + | + | × | × | × | × | + | + |
Parker 201215 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Lucio 201214 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Udeh 201318 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Cahill 201319 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Parker 201320 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Parker 201422 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Singh 201421 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Sulaiman 201423 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | × | + |
Maillard 201524 | + | + | + | × | × | × | × | + | + |
Vertuani 201526 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Gandhoke 201627 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Djurasovic201928 | + | + | + | × | × | × | + | + | + |
Note: “+” indicates presence and “x” indicates absence of the given quality.