Table 4

Criteria categories needed for coverage by recommendation set.

Categorya NASSEvicoreAIMOrthonetLifetime Health CareUPMCAetnaUnited
Radiculopathy/claudicationYYYN/AYYYY
Correlative lesion on imaging?YYYN/AYYYY
Degree of stenosis specified?NNNN/ANNYN
Duration of symptoms requirement?YNNN/ANNNY
Physical examination findings?NNYN/AYYNN
Documented physical examination?NYYN/ANNNN
Exclude untreated psychiatric patients?NYNN/AYNYN
Pain threshold? (On 10-point VAS scale)N73N/A7NNN
Epidural injection necessary?NNNN/ANYNN
Physical therapy necessary?NNYN/ANYNN
Duration of conservative management?4 wk6 wk6 wkN/A6 wk12 wk6 wk4 wk
Mandate a trial of medical treatment?NNNN/ANYNN
Total categories needed for coverage467N/A5754
  • Abbreviations: AIM, American Imaging Management; N/A, not available; NASS, North American Spine Society; UPMC, University of Pittsburgh Medical Center; VAS, visual analog scale.

  • a Subcategories required for coverage of surgical intervention.