Table 3

The treatment modalities used in the studies relevant to Garg’s classification and salient findings of the studies.

AuthorsGarg’s
Classification
Treatment ModalityAssessed
Outcome
Parameters
Conclusion
and Salient Findings
Peng et al10 Unclear about grades I or II; A: 3 patients; B: 5 patients; III: 1 patientChemotherapy: 8 patients;
Chemotherapy + surgery: 1 patient
At last follow-up, MRI images revealed disappearance of soft tissue shadow.Chemotherapy is safe and effective. Surgery is indicated for spinal instability or with severe neurological deficit.
Jiang L et al11 Not providedChemotherapy + local radiotherapy: 1 (case 1)
Radiotherapy: 2 (cases 2 and 5)
Surgery: 1 (case 3)
radiotherapy + surgery: 1 (case 4)
Clinical symptoms resolved at last follow-up.Chemotherapy is highly effective. Surgery in lesions causing neurology which are not amenable to chemotherapy or radiotherapy.
Abdelaal et al12 UnclearNonoperative treatment: 11
Surgery: 2
Died: 2 (by mean 27 months on nonoperative treatment)
Vertebral body height restoration.Nonoperative treatment yields results. Surgery is indicated when the lesion is in cervical spine.
Nakamura et al13 Not providedBrace: 9 patients, of which 8 patients had systemic chemotherapy + brace
Supervised management: 4 patients
Anterior, posterior vertebral wall height restoration.Vertebral body height restoration occurs eventually with treatment. It can be assessed by measuring the height of anterior, posterior vertebral body wall height.
Zhou et al14 Not providedSurgery only: 6
Surgery + radiation therapy: 9
Surgery + chemotherapy: 4
Surgery + radiotherapy
+ chemotherapy: 4
Radiotherapy: 5
Chemotherapy: 1
Radiotherapy + chemotherapy: 2
Local pain relief and neurological improvement following surgery.Surgery followed by postoperative low-dose radiation therapy or chemotherapy provides prompt local pain relief and early neurological improvement when compared with isolated radiation therapy or chemotherapy alone.
Zheng et al15 Grade IITranspedicular curettage + short segment posterior instrumentation, balloon kyphoplasty, calcium sulfate cement injectionBetter vertebral height restoration by 2-y follow-up when compared with historical cohort.Active surgical treatment is recommended in patients with grade II lesions.
Zheng et al16 Grade IB and IITranspedicular curettage + short segment posterior instrumentation, Instrumentation removal by 2 yBetter vertebral body height restoration by 1-y follow-up when compared with reference vertebral body height.Active surgical treatment is recommended in patients with grade IB, II lesions to restore vertebral body height and spinal stability.
Zhong et al17 Not providedC1–C2: Anterior resection of lesion and posterior instrumentation
C3–C7:
Vertebral body lesion: anterior excision, corpectomy, and fusion
Posterior column lesion:
posterior excision and instrumentation
Improvement in neurology and clinical symptoms.Surgery can significantly improve neurological symptoms. However, it must be tailored according to the individual location of the lesion in cervical spine.
  • Abbreviation: MRI, magnetic resonance imaging.